Nov 8, 20262 min read

Why McArthur Wheeler put lemon juice on his face before two bank robberies

McArthur Wheeler thought lemon juice would hide his face from bank cameras. The surveillance tape showed otherwise.

Listen instead
Why McArthur Wheeler put lemon juice on his face before two bank robberies
0:00 / 0:52

The money moved, but McArthur Wheeler’s face stayed on tape. He thought lemon juice would hide him. It is the kind of detail that makes you stop and read it again: lemon juice, on his face, before a bank robbery.

Two banks near Pittsburgh

Wheeler robbed two banks near Pittsburgh. When police showed him the surveillance tape, he was there, face and all. Before going in, he had rubbed lemon juice on his face. The tape showed the face he had expected the cameras not to see.

He believed the juice would keep the cameras from seeing him, so he wore no mask. That left one visible face at two banks. The lemon juice was on his face, but it did not do what he believed it would do.

What the cameras showed

The cameras caught Wheeler both times. The money moved because he threatened people with a gun. The cameras worked because lemon juice did not hide his face. Both parts of the story matter: people faced a gun, and the surveillance images still showed Wheeler.

The footage did not leave his face out. Police identified him from the images and caught him later. The same face he had tried to hide with lemon juice was visible on the tape police showed him.

A question about judging ability

David Dunning and Justin Kruger read about Wheeler and began studying how people judge their own ability. Wheeler’s belief about the cameras became part of what they read before beginning that work.

There is a smaller, familiar version of misjudging yourself: reading a line back, hearing it sound perfect in your head, and then stumbling when you say it aloud. The words can seem right in your head and still come out differently.

Wheeler’s test was less forgiving. He believed lemon juice would keep the cameras from seeing him, but they caught him at both banks. His face was on tape.

Share

Get new stories in your inbox

You'll get an email when a new story arrives. No schedule, no spam, just the next tale.

We'll send one email to confirm it's you.

Keep going

More like this